Pages

Sunday, December 4, 2011

Falling Prey to Twilight - the Saga - Part II - "Twilight and the Myth"

In my last blog post I admitted that I fell into the Twilight black hole. There, I was mesmerized by passion and romance and adventure and mystery; it lasted until I read the words “The End”. At that point, I felt the acute angst of the forces of real life pull me back; kind of like the scene from Somewhere in Time – an old Christopher Reeve and Jayne Seymour movie – the scene where Reeve's character pulls the penny out of his pocket dated 1979, and his passion and romance and mystery back-in-time world which he had arrived at via time travel came to an anguishing abrupt halt.

I asked the question: Why? Why me? Why a good portion of the rest of the world? Did you know that Twilight has been translated into 37 languages – all with differing cover artwork that expresses the spirit of the book in unique cultures?

I heard from a few of my good Christian friends after the last blog post. They asked the question “Should I read it”? Hard question to answer. If you are looking for something to build your faith, strengthen your character, or add to your library of great literary works, no, at least, not directly. But, I further told them I loved them, and urged them to give it a try if they don’t mind the month-long hangover when finished (read the part above about the forces of real life pulling you back).

I googled “Twilight from a Christian perspective” and got some interesting viewpoints. I’ll put a couple of links here if you are interested in taking a look.

http://christianteens.about.com/od/christianentertainment/a/TwilightDebate.htm

In these articles you’ll see how many Christians have concerns that the main characters of the story are vampires, which, traditionally, have no souls and are inhabited by evil spirits. They struggle with some moral gray areas in relation to Bella, who wrestles with her fleshly desire of Edward, and is somewhat ho-hum when considering giving up her soul in order to be with Edward forever.

On the flip side, some Christians (including me) praise Twilight because abstinence remains to Edward a non-negotiable, to which he stays true until marriage despite immense desire. They also laud the portrayal of the characters’ high esteem for the value of human life, and for its treatment of the weighty importance of one’s soul – at least in Edwards’ mind.

But again, I’m not trying to determine if Twilight is worthy for Christian eyes, whether they be fourteen-year-old or forty-year-old eyes. It appears there has been plenty written on that. I’d like to go a little deeper, below the upper crust of moral fiber down into the hot magma that is drawing people down into it – to live there for a while, and when done with the books, to want to stay there.

I’d like to go down into the magma of myth.

You see, I think we miss the heart of our story as Christians when we behave as if all that matters is morality. Absolutely this is important, but, we need to go deeper to see why it is important, and what motivates us to act - what lies at the core of who we are, what we were made for, what we desire, what we ache for. Where does love and longing come from? Deep down in the magma of our souls. Remember we are made in the image of God, and He loves and He longs and He desires, or else, we would not exist, because He WANTED us and still WANTS us (I know, most days that’s hard to believe).

Thanks to the Enlightenment period which preceded us, we are all about facts and numbers and efficiency and bullet points and logic and intellect. The heart, (which actually has more to do with our decision making than we realize) is no longer needed. So, to get down to this level of the heart, we need a little help.

This is where stories come in to play. Fairy tales.  Myths - not in the sense of something many believe but that is not true (thanks, Enlightment period for “enlightening us” on this derivative meaning of myth). Myth - meaning, a story that uncovers something. A story that digs something up within us that makes us feel something because of the way that God designed us. John Eldredge calls myth “a story that brings you a glimpse of the eternal”, and then he quotes a Christian professor Rolland Hein “Myths are, first of all, stories: stories which confront us with something transcendent and eternal…a means by which the eternal expresses itself in time” (1).

This, my friends, is what I believe the Twilight series has done. It has dug up something in millions of people; something many are completely oblivious to. They are staring at something eternal, something real for which they were created, but are not only unaware of what it is, but what to do with it.

What is it that this series digs up, that stares us in the face after “the End”? Let's talk - see next blog.

(1)    Waking the Dead, John Eldredge, p 25

By the way, I’m assuming all who are reading this have either read the books or seen the movies and am aware of the storyline. If not, and you are interested, here are some good summaries:

http://cliffnotebooks.com/tag/twilight - Cliff Notes of all 4 books, starting with the last book
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twilight_%28series%29  - short overviews – see “Plot Overview”

7 comments:

Lynnette Dobberpuhl said...

Thank you for giving a more intellectual foundation for my love of stories of superheroes, scifi epics, and even some cartoons (The Airbender.) It is easy to feel that writing novels is frivolous entertainment but your argument justifies the significance of what we storytellers hope to accomplish. I look forward to the next one!

cindythea said...

Amy, I have not had the privilege to read yet, next week the Sem career ends so this will be on my list of reading material....
While I cannot say I have read, I can say that I resonate with the raw, earthy quality of which you speak. It boils down to passion...passion that wells up within us and calls us to places of deep and deeper. Passion that we are afraid to admit exists because it may cause us to go to places that are uncomfortable or make us acknowledge our human-ness. The same passion that God placed in us that motivates us to gravitate toward a relationship, b/c it was placed there by God.
WE forget the fact that we are pursued-ardently, jealously; like a lover pursues his intended, and gentle like a mother, and intentional as a Savior. It blows my mind that this is a taste of the joy we are to experience, that we cannot even imagine the whole package that awaits us...and the Lord who set it in motion wants to share that with any of us...including me. Pursued...the Lord pursues me?
As I watch young people and even us Gen Xers (yes you too, Amy) I am convinced of the great yearning that exists for something more-more raw, more real, more authentic. WE yearn for it body and soul, for deeper relationship, more truth, and it scares the crap out of us. WE want to know that others will stand in the crap with us and are bowled over when someone actually does...and if not careful and dutifully tended with a relationship with Christ and fellowship in the body, the yearning is filled with something else. At the end of the day, we are still left hankering for me...chomping at the bit as it were.
How do we journey with one another to create safe places to articulate that, to invite raw conversation in churches, at home, on the street...over coffee and a blog. I do not have the answers, but the need is there for me as well...the deep need to hear and be heard. Maybe I know nothing, but this is where drew me. In the grit and the grime, the mud and the sludge is supreme beauty and redemption...that is all i know, for now....shalom.

Amy Gusso said...

Lynette - no, I'm afraid your endeavor carries way more weight than mere entertainment. Bringing one's heart out into the open for examination and change? I'd say that's a big job. ;-) Thanks Lynnette!

Amy Gusso said...

Cindy, you say it well, esp your last sentence. Pursued? Yes, it's true...via stories, music, movies, other people...yip...sometimes we're just too blind to see it. Thanks for your thought-provoking words!

Tanya said...

Don't know what I think about the whole "Twilight" issue, but I am THRILLED that you are reading "Wuthering Heights." It has been my favorite book since high school - the only time I ever read it all the way through. It is the only book I ever put down because it was so intense it hurt to read it - but then I immediately picked it up again because I wanted to know what happened to Heathcliff and Catherine. I just love that story.

Amy Gusso said...

Tanya - Glad to hear you loved it! Yeah I started it but am having to put it down because I don't have the brain bandwidth for it now, but will pick it up after Christmas. I'm really looking forward to reading it...will let you know what I think! What are you reading these days?

Tanya said...

Amy, Wuthering Heights was MUCH easier to read in high school because the books came with a glossary to help us decipher the servants' dialects. Once in a while I still pick the book up, read and a little and remember why it sucked me in.

Rignt now I am reading Janet Evanovich. I read SO much for work that when I'm not working, I want vast quantities of brain candy! One of these days I might summon the coursage to go back to Ann Voskamp's "One Thousand Gifts."